Apr
23
YA Presence in Australia Shrinking
Posted in "Discussion" • 13 Comments

I know there are still new books coming out, both debuts and continuing series, but it seems like the market here is shrinking—or at least the market space allotted for YA. Borders are gone, Angus & Robertson are gone—even places like Collins are hard to come by. I went looking for one I knew of yesterday and found a Supré in its spot instead.

In Queensland, we still have QBD, and nationally, there’s Dymocks, but their YA sections are usually only a wall a metre to two metres wide, unless in you’re in the city. If it was 2012, I’d say sure, these stores have a good selection of books—and compared to the department stores, they still do. But I look at the book hauls many US bloggers are posting pics of, and it’s usually the first I’m seeing of the book. Are these even getting published here? And if they are, where are they?

Over the past month, I’ve been holidaying, going both to Brisbane and down to Melbourne’s CBD, checking out every bookstore, and department store with book sections that I could find. Dymocks in Melbourne’s CBD was massive, though it’s YA section wasn’t quite as good as the Brisbane one. Brisbane’s beat it by an extra row. Just about everywhere else that I went, though, was a letdown. For the life of me, I couldn’t find Anna and the French Kiss anywhere.

I don’t know why I bother going to Target or Kmart anymore. I used to love poring through their shelves, snatching up heaps of YA books at low-for-Australia prices. But now it seems like only Harlequin/Mills and Boon have any sort of presence there. It’s basically just a romance section now. The more popular titles like John Green’s back catalogue, The Hunger Games and Divergent are usually there, but I want to be able to discover new books when I’m out shopping, not just the latest craze.

Big W isn’t too bad, but you need to keep checking back regularly. Books pop up, and then a week later they’ll all be gone and you’ll never see it again. It’s weird, because there are a heap of others that seem like they’ve been sitting there since the store first opened, or at least the past couple of years. It’s why I keep checking every Big W whenever I’m at a new shopping centre. Each one has its own vault of treasures that haven’t been sent back to the publishers, just accumulating in a disorganised pile, behind the newer books on the shelves—you just have to dig through to find them. Still, if you’re after a certain book, it’s usually only pure luck if you find it.

I’d really like to be able to support our local market, but it feels like there is no supply, or at least no consistent supply, to meet the demand. It’s so much easier to just open my laptop and type in the book. Sure, it takes a couple weeks to get to me, but it’s usually cheaper and a lot less trouble than trying to track something down from store to store.

What do you think of the current offerings at Aussie bookstores? Am I just not finding the right stores or this happening to you too?

UPDATED: More pictures. And yes, the Twilight books are sitting in New Releases.

QBD (pictured below, on the left) beats all of my local bookstores, having a wider and more complete selection when it comes to stocking each book in a series. Though, it could do with some newer titles as most have been out for quite a while.

And what our shrinking YA sections seem to have made way for:

13 Responses to this Post
  • Brittany says:

    This is such a great post Brett, and I am going to be pimping it everywhere. I’ll even ask Felicity what she thinks of it. I love that you have photos too.

    I am SO SICK of just seeing ‘run of the mill’ books at places like BIG W, just whatever the craze is or the same book with 5 different covers…

    • Brett says:

      I’m not sure what the Big W staff were thinking of me doing my little photo shoot yesterday. I took a heap at all different angles and even stumbled about trying to do a panorama that didn’t make the cut.

      It’s good to know I’m not the only one feeling like this. Book shopping just isn’t as fun anymore when there’s nothing new to discover on the shelves. I went down to QBD today and they were still pushing the Hush, Hush books.

      • Brittany says:

        And QBD sells a single book for like $26 paperback. It’s ridiculous.

        I used to love doing the rounds – Kmart, Big W and Target… but now there’s just nothing

  • Jaz says:

    I completely agree with this! Target and Myer only ever stock the really popular titles. K-Mart is horrible now, I used to be able to find Brigid Kemmerer’s books there but not anymore. The only consistent titles I see are Harlequin’s books.

    Big W is hard for me to get to, but the chance I get I do find some good titles there.

    My only bet is going to the city and going to Dymocks and Kinokuniya. More often than not, I’ve asked Kino to order in a book that’s only published in the US and they’ll get it for me from their US supplier. But sometimes I just find it easier to go to the Book Depository.

    Can we also mention the fact that we get titles WAYYY slower than the US? Even if an Aussie pub has the rights and is publishing it here, a book on its release day is able to be instantly accessed by people in the US but in Aus, it depends on logistics – I once asked for a book and told them the release day and they said it’ll be available 2 weeks after release day! And we’re talking really anticipated titles (at least in the US they were).

    Great post, this is a serious issue. And people wonder why we buy online? I’ve resulted to pre-ordering the Ruin and Ruising Exclusive Special Edition from Barnes & Nobles (and paying more for shipping than the actual book) because I’ve heard nothing in Aus. There isn’t even a guarantee it’ll be out on release day.

    • Brett says:

      I’d forgotten all about Myer. It’s rare that I go in there. It seems like they only ever have five or six YA titles sitting sparsely on a shelf, the rest of their book department taken up by biographies, kids picture books and a bunch of coffee table books. Plus, everything is always at RRP there.

      I just looked up Kinokuniya because I hadn’t heard of it before. Whoa, the pictures on their site make it look huge. I think I need a trip to Sydney next holiday!

      I know what you mean about delays in releases. Look at the gap between the US and AUS release of Fangirl, and it was probably the biggest contemporary of the year. What was with that?

      • Jaz says:

        Definitely check out Kino. Their prices are the same as Dymocks but their selection is humongous! Our Sydney Dymocks is amazing too actually. I’m glad we have them both. Kino has a better selection internationally though – they stock like all the manga and graphic novels 😀

        They’re both great bookstores but still slow in terms of getting new releases. And HAH Fangirl I just got off TBD and read it before it came out here.

  • Hi Brett, I saw this post and hope you don’t mind me jumping in – I work for the online bookstore Bookworld (we’re actually the old Borders Online store) and wanted to let you know that there are definitely other alternatives to buying your YA from the overseas companies. We are based here in Australia and have a huge range of books – over 13 million titles – so we’re pretty confident that you should be able to find whatever you are after! Our audience loves YA so we do a heap with this category – we work in with the local publishers to pull together some really cool promotions and offers for the most exciting YA releases and often have really great discounts on YA books.

    I just checked and we have Anna & The French Kiss in our warehouse in Melbourne right now and could have it to you within a day or two. We also have free shipping on every order – to make it super easy.

    Would love for you to check us out before having to resort to the overseas guys – we’re all for supporting the local book sellers! 🙂

    • Brett says:

      Hi Kim, thanks for your input and letting me know about Anna. The issue here isn’t the lack of online alternatives, I think Bookworld definitely has its place for those who are being forced into online shopping and want to keep their money in Australia.

      What I’m worried about is the diminishing in-store presence. I used to love being able to make an adventure out of book shopping–discover new books I hadn’t heard of, pick them up and feel what the covers were made of, see if they were shiny or matte, look at the spine heights etc. Online shopping is more for those who know what they’re after.

  • Oh! So I’m not the only one who feels like this! Did you know, it was only recently that I had to actually HUNT down a copy of The Fault in Our Stars? They’re everywhere again now, but I couldn’t find it locally at all and it wasn’t even like places were sold out – they just weren’t stocking it. Book stores are becoming more and more challenging to find, and local online bookstores are often too expensive for me. Since the Kmart stores have all started “upgrading”, I swear their books section has been slashed to a quarter of what it used to be (less than that actually for my local one – it used to be decent, now there is just one small short aisle for all their books)! We worry about kids not reading, but stores just a) aren’t accessible, b) don’t offer enough variety/choice etc.

    xxMillicent

    • Brett says:

      I remember searching last year for John Green’s books too. I had to drive about all over town trying to find them, and now it feels like it’s the only thing you actually can find everywhere.

      My Kmart hasn’t “upgraded” its book section yet. The shelving space is the same size it’s always been, but it feels like there’s nothing there. Most of it is taken up by cookbooks, biographies and Mills and Boon. They have a single row for all general fiction with a few YA titles spread about through it, but only the ‘latest craze’ titles.

      It’s really sad for the younger YA readers as these stores made book buying affordable, and now they’re forced into paying RRP at places like Dymocks if they want to get a book in person. Either that, or getting their parents to shop online for them. And that’s if they know about the books in the first place. For the casual reader who uses in-store discovery to choose what to read, all they’re left with is Divergent and The Fault In Our Stars at the moment.

  • I could not agree with you more. I hate that I have to buy books online but they are way cheaper and I know that 99% of the time, they will have the books I want but it’s really the only way. My Big W has a pretty decent amount of books but the YA sections is only 1 ‘bookcase’ long with 4 shelves and most of the time that I go, there isn’t much of a selection. Or when they have the 3rd of 4th book into a series, umm where is the 1st.
    What even makes it worse is my local target, the shelving is horrible they have about 20 boxed shelves with most being the same book…I just don’t get it or understand it.
    I wrote a post similar in a way to this a few months ago about Book Stores in Australia
    Yes! People in the US not only I think have a pretty much endless supply of books but they more than likely get the books first and we sometimes have to wait months before we see a book published in Australia, as a reader and a blogger It really makes me angry in a way waiting so long for a book!
    It really disappoints me that we barley have any YA range here in Australia, especially since some of the biggest fanbase’s for books are from here, for example Australia has the biggest fanbase for the Vampire Academy Series. None of this makes sense at all.
    Thanks for a really good post.

    • Brett says:

      Your Big W sounds pretty much like mine that I posted the photo of. I agree with on the 3rd or 4th book thing–trying to find earlier books in a series after the new one is out is near impossible. It’s like they just go out of print–especially with HarlequinTeen books.

      You should see my local Target. I went there tonight and their A-Z YA section had nearly every ‘square’ of their display wall sitting empty, all except for a couple copies of City of Ashes, and some children’s books. I just don’t understand the logic behind it. How is an empty shelf good for business?

Leave a Reply